Win rate alone does not tell you whether a strategy is good: you can win 70% of the time and lose money, or win 35% and come out ahead. Two figures summarize expected performance far more honestly: expectancy and profit factor. This guide shows how to calculate them, how to interpret them and how far you can trust them.
The expectancy formula
Expectancy is what you win or lose, on average, per trade over the long run. The formula is E = (WR × average win) − ((1 − WR) × average loss), where WR is the proportion of winning trades (win rate), expressed between 0 and 1. If E is positive, the strategy wins on average; if it is negative, it loses, however good it looks.
You can express it in money, but it is more useful in R multiples, where 1 R is what you risk on each trade. That lets you compare systems with different account sizes or position sizes. If E = 0.2 R, then for every 100 USD risked you expect to earn 20 USD on average, after accounting for losses.
First example: winning rarely and still profiting
A strategy wins 40% of the time, makes 2 R on average when it wins and loses 1 R when it fails. E = 0.40 × 2 − 0.60 × 1 = 0.80 − 0.60 = +0.20 R. With 100 trades and 100 USD risked on each, expectancy is 20 USD per trade, or 2,000 USD in total (an average, not a guarantee).
Check it against a sample of ten trades in R: +2, −1, −1, +2, −1, +2, −1, −1, +2, −1. Four win (+8 R) and six lose (−6 R); the net is +2 R, which divided by 10 gives 0.20 R, and the win rate is 40%. Notice there are two pairs of consecutive losses in just ten trades: that is normal for this kind of system.
Second example: winning often and losing money
Now a system that wins 60% of the time but makes only 0.5 R on average and loses 1 R when it fails. E = 0.60 × 0.5 − 0.40 × 1 = 0.30 − 0.40 = −0.10 R. Even though it wins six times out of ten, it loses 0.10 R per trade: with 100 trades and 100 USD of risk, that is −1,000 USD on average.
This is a very common pattern among traders who close winners early out of fear and let losers run. The lesson is that win rate on its own is a misleading number: it only makes sense together with the relationship between average win and average loss.
Relationship with the risk/reward ratio
The minimum win rate needed to avoid losing money (the break-even point) depends on the R:R ratio: minimum WR = 1 ÷ (1 + R:R). With 1:1 you need 50%; with 1:2, 33.3%; with 1:3, 25%; and with 1:0.5 (you win half of what you risk), 66.7%. Any win rate above that point gives positive expectancy before costs.
That is why there is no universal “good” win rate. Trend-following systems tend to have low win rates (30 to 40%) with large wins, and mean-reversion systems high win rates with small wins. Either can be profitable or not: E decides. You can calculate the R:R of each trade with our risk/reward calculator.
The profit factor
The profit factor (PF) is the ratio of gross profit to gross loss: PF = sum of all gains ÷ sum of all losses (in absolute value). A PF of 1 is break-even, above 1 is profitable and below 1 is losing. In the first example: gains = 0.40 × 2 = 0.80 R per trade and losses = 0.60 R, so PF = 0.80 ÷ 0.60 ≈ 1.33. In the second: 0.30 ÷ 0.40 = 0.75.
There is a direct link with expectancy: PF = 1 + E ÷ ((1 − WR) × average loss). In the first example, 1 + 0.20 ÷ 0.60 = 1.33, the same as before. Expectancy tells you how much you earn per trade; PF tells you how much you earn for each unit lost. With real data PF is very sensitive to one or two extreme trades, so do not rely on it alone.