When you open a position on EUR/USD, the S&P 500 or gold, the screen looks almost identical in all three cases, yet what happens behind it is very different. You might own the asset, hold a contract with your broker, or hold a standardized contract traded on an exchange. This guide explains what you buy in each case, what it costs and which risks each format adds, so you can choose deliberately rather than out of habit.
The key question: what do you take home?
Before comparing costs or leverage, it helps to pin down the essential difference: each format gives you something different in exchange for your money. In the spot market you buy the asset itself. With a CFD you sign a contract with your broker whose value follows the asset. With a future you buy a standardized contract with an expiry date, traded on an exchange and backed by a clearing house.
Almost everything else follows from that: who your counterparty is, what you pay to hold the position, what happens if the broker fails, and which rights you have (such as voting at a shareholder meeting or receiving a dividend). None of them is “better” in the abstract; each fits a different use.
Spot: buying and owning the asset
If you buy one hundred shares on an exchange or one bitcoin on a crypto exchange, you are the owner. You pay the full value (unless you borrow separately), you can hold the position for years with no financing charge, and there is no expiry. When you buy, your maximum loss is what you invested, because the asset cannot be worth less than zero. Selling short is different: you must borrow the asset, which is not always available or cheap.
One clarification about forex: the “spot” currency market offered by retail brokers does not mean you receive euros or dollars. It is settled virtually, and if you hold a position overnight a swap is applied. In practice it is a contract with the broker that behaves much like a CFD on currencies. Shares and cryptocurrencies bought without leverage, on the other hand, are genuinely yours, with the custody question that comes with that: either the broker or exchange holds your assets, or you do.
CFDs: a contract for difference with your broker
A contract for difference (CFD) is an agreement to exchange the difference between the opening and closing price. You do not receive the share, the barrel of oil or the index: you only gain or lose the difference. It trades over the counter, which means your counterparty is the broker, who sets the price you see and handles execution.
The appeal is flexibility: small sizes, many markets from one account, easy short selling and leverage. The drawback is the one most often underestimated: there is no ownership and no shareholder rights (on shares, a dividend adjustment replaces the dividend, but you do not vote), you depend on the broker’s solvency and practices, and holding positions carries a daily financing cost.
Futures: standardized contracts with an expiry
A future is a contract to buy or sell an asset at an agreed price on a future date, with size and features set by the exchange. For example, the E-mini S&P 500 (ES) is worth 50 USD per index point, with a minimum tick of 0.25 points (12.50 USD); the Micro E-mini (MES) is worth 5 USD per point. WTI crude oil (CL) covers 1,000 barrels and its 0.01 tick is worth 10 USD.
Because they trade on a central exchange, the price is public and a clearing house stands between buyer and seller, which reduces counterparty risk. In return, contracts expire: ES contracts expire in March, June, September and December, while crude oil expires monthly. To keep your exposure you must move to the next expiry (the “roll”). Stock index futures settle in cash; in commodities such as oil there is physical delivery, and retail brokers usually close the position before that date.
Leverage: the same move in three wrappers
Suppose a share trades at 50 USD and you buy 100 of them. In spot you pay 5,000 USD. With a CFD at 5:1 leverage (the usual maximum for individual shares for retail clients in the European Union) you tie up only 1,000 USD of margin. If the share rises by 4 USD you make 400 USD in both cases: 8% on the 5,000 USD, but 40% on the margin. If it falls by 4 USD you lose 400 USD, which is 40% of the margin you deposited.
Leverage does not change the value of the position; it changes how much of your own capital you put up against it. Futures work the same way with different figures: with the ES at 5,000 points, one contract represents 5,000 × 50 = 250,000 USD of exposure, and a micro contract 25,000 USD. A 20-point move is 1,000 USD on the ES and 100 USD on the MES. Required margin depends on the exchange and the broker and changes with volatility, so check it before trading. Our margin calculator shows how much capital a position ties up.
Costs: spread, commission, financing and roll
Each format charges differently. On CFDs and forex you pay the spread (the gap between bid and ask) and, depending on the account, a commission. On EUR/USD with 0.5 lots and a 1.2 pip spread, the entry cost is 1.2 × 10 × 0.5 = 6 USD. On an account with a raw spread of 0.2 pips and a commission of 7 USD per round-trip lot, it would be 0.2 × 10 × 0.5 = 1 USD plus 7 × 0.5 = 3.50 USD, or 4.50 USD in total. The account that looks cheaper is not always the cheaper one: it depends on how much you trade.
Financing (swap in forex, overnight adjustment on index or share CFDs) is charged for holding a position overnight and is usually a benchmark rate plus a broker markup. At an illustrative annual rate of 7%, a long position of 25,000 USD pays 25,000 × 0.07 ÷ 365 ≈ 4.79 USD per day, about 143.84 USD over 30 days. Futures have no explicit financing charge: the cost of carrying the asset is already built into the contract price. You pay broker commission and exchange fees per contract per side, and when you roll you cross the spread twice (close one contract, open another). The price difference between two expiries is not a loss in itself, but a badly adjusted continuous chart can mislead you in a backtest.